top of page

The Catwick Blacksmith and the Lucky Horseshoe

6 days ago
4 min read

The Catwick Blacksmith and the Lucky Horseshoe

Some of Yorkshire's best stories aren't carved in stone. In the small Holderness village of Catwick, between Leven and Hornsea, one of them was nailed to a wooden doorpost.

It belongs to the village blacksmith, John Hugill, a lucky horseshoe and a row of coins – one for every man who left Catwick to fight in the First World War.

Every one of them came home.

It's exactly the kind of tale we started Yorkshire's Stories to tell – a small place with a story most people drive straight past.


A Village With No War Memorial

Most English villages have a memorial listing the men who never returned. Catwick doesn't, and the reason is a happy one.

Catwick is a Thankful Village – one of the rare places where everyone who served in the First World War survived. The term comes from the writer Arthur Mee, who used it in his King's England guides in the 1930s. Only five have been identified in Yorkshire: Catwick, Cundall, Helperthorpe, Norton-le-Clay and Scruton.

Catwick goes one better. It lost no one in the Second World War either, making it one of only 14 Doubly Thankful villages in England and Wales – and, according to the Pocklington Post, the only one in Yorkshire.


A Coin for Every Man

Thirty men from Catwick went to the Great War. As they left, a coin was nailed up beside a lucky horseshoe at the village forge.

Accounts differ slightly on who did the nailing. The National Churches Trust says it was John Hugill himself, adding a coin near the horseshoe on his forge doorpost for each man. The Pocklington Post describes each man nailing his own coin to the forge before leaving the village. Either way, the forge became Catwick's quiet record of who had gone.

Most of the coins were ordinary pennies and halfpennies, but the collection also includes one German coin and one Swiss coin. How those two ended up on a Holderness forge isn't recorded.


All Thirty Came Home

All thirty men returned, though not all of them unscathed. Joseph Grantham, who served with the East Yorkshire Regiment, lost an arm.

There's also a village tale that a notch was cut from one coin to mark a man who came home missing part of a limb. The newspaper that repeated it called it a rumour, so we'd treat it as a story rather than established history.

One other name appears in the reporting: T. Jordan of Catwick, listed as Wagoner 686.


Thirty More Coins in the Second World War

When war came again, the tradition carried on. Another thirty men went from Catwick, another thirty coins went up beside the horseshoe – and once again, every one of them returned.

John Hugill worked as the village blacksmith through both world wars, so the forge that saw the first thirty men off saw the second thirty go too.

Horses were part of this story as well. Many local horses, including Wolds wagon teams, were requisitioned in both wars and very few came back. Catwick has since held a Horseman's Sunday on the village green to recognise the part they played.


Where the Horseshoe Is Now

When the forge eventually closed, the horseshoe and coins were taken down and fixed to a plaque. When the Pocklington Post reported the story, the plaque belonged to the blacksmith's grandson, also called John Hugill.

We haven't been able to confirm where it is today, so please don't expect to find it on display in the village.


Visiting Catwick

Catwick sits on the A1035 between Leven and Hornsea, so it pairs well with a day on the East Yorkshire coast. St Michael's Church on Church Lane (HU17 5PW) is listed by the National Churches Trust as open every day. Inside you'll find a medieval holy water stoup and a carved stone of the Archangel Michael set into the chancel wall. The tower is old, but much of the church was rebuilt in 1863.

On Main Street, look out for two very worn stone columns with scalloped capitals set into a brick gateway at The Old Rectory. They're said to have come from the church when it was rebuilt.

Opening arrangements can change, so check before making a special trip to see the church.

We're heading to Catwick for a walk soon, and we'll add the route to our East Yorkshire walks once we've done it.


Explore More


Michael and Lyn – The White Shire, Yorkshire first-hand. We came across the Catwick blacksmith's story while planning our walk around the village, and it's one of the most human pieces of Yorkshire history we've found.


DON'T MISS YORKSHIRE

Get new walks, places to visit, What's On picks and Yorkshire discoveries from Mick & Lyn at The White Shire.



Click on the links below to listen to our podcasts



  • Amazon Podcasts
  • Apple Podcasts
  • Spotify
  • Youtube Podcasts

Comments


bottom of page